How to Choose a PMC or Redevelopment Consultant

Under a Government of Maharashtra circular issued in January 2009 (and reinforced by amendments to Section 79A of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act), appointing a Project Management Consultant is now effectively a first legal step for any cooperative housing society considering redevelopment in Mumbai. Yet most societies approach this appointment with far less scrutiny than…

Under a Government of Maharashtra circular issued in January 2009 (and reinforced by amendments to Section 79A of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act), appointing a Project Management Consultant is now effectively a first legal step for any cooperative housing society considering redevelopment in Mumbai. Yet most societies approach this appointment with far less scrutiny than they’ll later apply to the developer itself — which is backwards, since a weak PMC is often the reason a society ends up with a weak developer in the first place.

Is your society considering redevelopment? Get a free first assessment of your plot from Mungekar Realty: what it can support, which regulation applies and what to watch out for. The society pays us nothing. Register your property or WhatsApp us on +91 98207 44734.

What a PMC actually does

A PMC is typically not one person but a small team: an architect or structural engineer, often supported by a chartered accountant and someone experienced in coordinating with municipal offices. Together, they assess your building’s technical feasibility, work out the FSI and TDR the plot is realistically entitled to, draft and issue the tender inviting developer proposals, evaluate the bids that come in, and support the society through drafting the Development Agreement. Within two months of appointment, a competent PMC should deliver a feasibility report to your committee — if a PMC can’t commit to that timeline, that’s worth noting early.

The credentials worth actually checking

A reasonable starting bar: the PMC’s architect should hold a valid license from the Council of Architecture and be recognised by the local municipal corporation, and any structural engineer on the team should be licensed with MCGM. Beyond paper qualifications, ask for at least three completed redevelopment projects that have received an Occupation Certificate (OC) — not just projects that have broken ground, since a PMC’s real test is whether their projects actually finish. Ask for the society contacts on those projects and call them. A PMC’s own sales pitch will always sound competent; a former client society, three years into living in the finished building, will tell you what actually happened.

Neutrality is the single most important quality

The PMC works for your society, not for any developer, and this needs to be true in practice, not just on paper. Ask directly whether the PMC has any ongoing commercial relationship with developers likely to bid for your project — referral arrangements, past joint projects, informal understandings. A PMC who has quietly steered several societies toward the same developer over the years is not bringing you an independent, competitive process; they’re bringing you a pre-selected outcome dressed up as one. This is precisely the kind of quiet conflict of interest that’s hardest for a society to spot on its own and easiest for an experienced outside advisor to flag.

Local knowledge genuinely matters

A PMC with deep, specific familiarity with your ward’s municipal office, your building’s zoning classification, and recent comparable redevelopments in your immediate neighbourhood will move your project faster and negotiate more credibly than one working from generic templates. Ask what other projects they’ve handled within a two-kilometre radius of your building, and what FSI and TDR those projects actually achieved once complete, not just what was initially projected — the gap between projection and outcome tells you a great deal about a PMC’s realism.

Fee structure and who actually pays

PMC fees are usually structured as a percentage of the project’s construction cost, a fixed retainer, or a combination of both, and in most well-negotiated redevelopment agreements, the developer bears the PMC’s fee rather than the society — since the PMC’s oversight work continues throughout construction, benefiting the project as a whole. Get this fee structure in writing before the PMC starts work, including what happens if the redevelopment process stalls or is abandoned partway through, so your society isn’t left holding an open-ended bill for work that never concluded.

Questions worth asking every shortlisted PMC

Beyond credentials and references, a short, direct conversation with each shortlisted PMC reveals a great deal. Ask them to walk through, in specific terms, how they’d approach your building — not a generic redevelopment process, but your plot’s actual FSI potential, likely challenges given its location and road width, and a realistic timeline. A PMC who gives you a thoughtful, building-specific answer on the spot is very different from one who recites the same pitch they’d give any society in the city. Ask how they handle disagreement within a managing committee, since redevelopment negotiations often surface exactly this kind of internal friction, and a PMC needs to be able to navigate it without simply deferring to whichever faction is loudest.

A word on selecting a PMC transparently

Just as with developer selection, the PMC appointment itself should go through a reasonably competitive process — shortlist at least three or four candidates, present them at a general body meeting, and let members see the comparison rather than having the managing committee simply announce a decision. This matters for the same reason competitive developer tendering matters: a PMC appointed through a visibly fair process starts the entire redevelopment journey on a foundation of trust that pays dividends much later, when harder, more contentious decisions need to be made.

Where an outside advisor fits in

Many societies find it useful to have an independent land and redevelopment advisor look over PMC proposals before committing — someone whose only stake in the outcome is the society getting a fair, technically sound process, without a referral relationship with any particular PMC or developer clouding the recommendation. This is exactly the kind of independent check we provide at Mungekar Realty: reviewing PMC credentials and proposals, cross-checking feasibility numbers against what a plot is genuinely entitled to under current DCPR rules, and helping a committee ask the right questions before signing anything. If your society is at the stage of shortlisting a PMC, we’re happy to have that conversation with you.

Related reading: self-redevelopment vs. builder-led redevelopment, and a due diligence checklist for evaluating a redevelopment site.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and educational purposes only. It is not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules change from time to time and every property is different, so please consult a qualified advocate, chartered accountant or architect before acting on it.
अस्वीकरण: हा लेख केवळ सर्वसाधारण माहिती आणि शैक्षणिक हेतूसाठी आहे; तो कायदेशीर, कर किंवा आर्थिक सल्ला नाही.
अस्वीकरण: यह लेख केवल सामान्य जानकारी और शैक्षिक उद्देश्य के लिए है; यह कानूनी, कर या वित्तीय सलाह नहीं है।